David Foster Wallace Consider The Lobster
Introduction
David Foster Wallace was a renowned American author known for his postmodern novels and essays. One of his most famous essays is "Consider the Lobster", published in 2004. In this essay, Wallace explores the ethics surrounding the consumption of lobsters and whether they can feel pain. He also delves into the culture of lobster festivals and the moral implications of boiling lobsters alive.
Background
David Foster Wallace was born in 1962 in Ithaca, New York. He attended Amherst College, where he majored in English and philosophy. After graduating from college, Wallace went on to pursue a career in writing. He wrote several novels, including "Infinite Jest" and "The Broom of the System".
Wallace was known for his unique writing style, which included footnotes, stream-of-consciousness, and experimental techniques. He often explored complex themes such as addiction, depression, and the human condition. His writing was widely celebrated, and he was considered one of the most influential writers of his generation.
The Essay
"Consider the Lobster" was originally published in Gourmet magazine in 2004. The essay was later included in Wallace's book "Consider the Lobster and Other Essays".
In the essay, Wallace begins by describing the annual Maine Lobster Festival. He notes the joy and excitement that the festival brings to the community, but also acknowledges the ethical concerns surrounding the consumption of lobsters. Wallace questions whether lobsters are capable of feeling pain and whether it is moral to boil them alive.
Wallace explores the science behind lobster anatomy and behavior, arguing that lobsters may indeed be capable of feeling pain. He draws on the work of scientists and animal rights activists to make his case.
Wallace also delves into the cultural significance of lobster festivals, arguing that they are a reflection of our society's relationship to nature and animals. He questions whether we have the right to consume animals for our own pleasure and whether we should be more mindful of the impact that our actions have on the natural world.
Critical Analysis
"Consider the Lobster" is a complex and thought-provoking essay that raises important questions about ethics and morality. Wallace's writing style is engaging and accessible, and he makes a compelling case for his argument.
One of the strengths of the essay is Wallace's use of scientific research to support his claims. He draws on the work of neuroscientists and animal rights activists to argue that lobsters are capable of feeling pain. This scientific evidence strengthens his argument and makes it more convincing.
Wallace also uses humor to lighten the tone of the essay and make it more accessible to readers. He pokes fun at the absurdity of lobster festivals and the human tendency to justify our actions, even when they may be morally questionable.
However, some critics have argued that Wallace's essay is overly sentimental and anthropomorphic. They argue that he anthropomorphizes lobsters, exaggerates their pain response, and oversimplifies the science behind their behavior.
Conclusion
"Consider the Lobster" is a powerful and thought-provoking essay that raises important questions about ethics and morality. Wallace's use of scientific research and humor make the essay engaging and accessible, while his arguments are compelling and thought-provoking.
Ultimately, the essay challenges readers to think more deeply about the impact of our actions on the natural world and the ethical implications of our food choices. "Consider the Lobster" is a must-read for anyone interested in animal rights, ethics, or the environment.